L.C. Killingsworth wasn’t quite prepared for her post-pandemic visit to The Greenbrier, the historic 5-star hotel in West Virginia.
Expecting classic luxury, she instead met a cacophony of colors, patterns, and fabrics strewn hotel-wide, surely by a “colorblind lunatic.”
Already juggling the chaos of reentering society with two young kids, the hotel’s assault on her senses was a uniquely strange yet balancing experience. She had to write it down.
After a year of work, she submitted the piece for publication.
Then came a rejection. And another. And another.
After 18 of them, Killingsworth found a place for her memoir essay — “Everything’s Fine at The Greenbrier!” — in Swamp Pink. Not just an acceptance — also the literary magazine’s annual prize for nonfiction and $2,000.
Killingsworth spoke with A Working Title about crafting the award-winning piece and its road to publication.
Pushing through 18 rejections
The essay started with “10,000 words of craziness,” and then Killingsworth shaped it and cut 2,000 words.
“I wanted every word to be right because when you’re describing a place, you really want to be specific about it: What is the exact right verb to describe what this door did to my psyche?” Killingsworth said.
Some of the well-established literary magazines have an acceptance rate of less than 1%. Publications and contests that pay are always more competitive. So rejection wasn’t a surprise.
“Rejections are nice. It’s the radio silence that kills you,” Killingsworth said.
Among the form rejections, Killingsworth said an editor sometimes included a message praising the piece despite it not being a fit for that respective issue. That’s helpful in an otherwise discouraging process.
“When you get those nice rejections, that’ll keep you going for a while,” she said.
During the submission process, it’s important to research a respective publication’s style, rules, themes, and even the editors’ likes and preferences.
She knew that Swamp Pink, for example, was open to longer essays. At 8,000 words, Killingsworth’s piece is about twice as long as many publications would accept.
Finally, she got the acceptance email with a blurb from judge Zara Chowdhary:
“… Every line sings for its dinner. … This voice, like all the finest voices of our time, will make you feel less crazy, and certainly less alone.”
“Which was worth more than the prize money to me,” Killingsworth said.
What’s Next
Killingsworth said she is revising existing essays with plans to develop a memoir manuscript.
That’s in between her day job as a marketing director for a consulting firm.
“I think the best piece of advice that I have is to find a day job that you like and that gives you stability and that leaves you enough mental space to write,” Killingsworth said. “You don’t want to find yourself trying to push stuff out there that’s not ready yet just because you are trying to get paid for it.”
Killingsworth started writing again in 2023.
In 2025, she was awarded a $20,000 grant as part of the NRDC Climate Storytelling Fellowship, which included industry mentorship to develop a TV pilot.
More important than the prizes, she said: “They’re opportunities to meet really cool people, and more often, it’s the people who keep you going.”


