Today is harder than ever to get a book traditionally published. Then it can take another two years before it hits shelves. And it likely won’t make much money.
For the many authors with stories to tell, Reid Tracy has a message: “The great news is that it’s easier than ever to self-publish.”
And, he said, it may be the best path for getting traditionally published.
Tracy is the CEO of book publisher Hay House, which Penguin Random House acquired in 2023.
He spoke on the topic along with Kelly Notaras — a book editor who has worked for HarperCollins, Penguin USA, and Hyperion Books — during a session for a recent Hay House Writers Bootcamp.
They cited Amazon KDP and IngramSpark as the top self-publishing services. And Simon & Schuster said earlier this year that its Pocket Books imprint is now focusing on publishing books from self-published authors.
They also heavily promoted Hay House-owned Balboa Press, which offers self-publishing services in partnership with Author Solutions. Advocacy groups have widely criticized Author Solutions for what they say are predatory sales practices, as well as charging thousands of dollars in fees.
The Alliance of Independent Authors has a watchdog list for “shady practices” in the industry, as well as a list of vetted services.
Regardless, the business realities of modern publishing apply.
Below are highlights of their self-publishing advice.
Self-publishing tests the market and could increase your chances of traditional publication
Notaras said self-publishing a book — as long as it sells well — can increase the chances that a traditional publisher buys the rights.
“It’s not plan B anymore; it’s step one,” Notaras said. “It’s where you get to test drive your idea for your book on real people in the marketplace and see whether it resonates.”
She added: “Publishers are actually even more interested in picking up the rights to your book than taking a flier on somebody who’s never published a book … It gives them something that publishers are really looking for, which is reduced risk in terms of taking on your project.”
This is true for all genres, but especially non-fiction books.
While big publishers pick up fiction books primarily for the story, they rarely buy nonfiction books if the author is not already famous.
Tracy said that Hay House and all of the major publishers would expect nonfiction authors to already have hundreds of thousands, or even millions, of social media followers.
“You’re not going to find a traditional publisher if you don’t have that,” Tracy said.
Low barrier of entry
It can take 18 to 24 months from the time a publisher buys your book until it hits shelves.
“If you want your book out in 2027, definitely, self-publishing would be the way to go,” Notaras said.
Between securing an agent, the time, and other commitments, self-publishing requires a much lower barrier of entry.
“Literary agents will basically take on a book they think they can sell. They do not take money until they’ve sold your book, which means their barrier to entry is very high. They need to deeply believe that your book is going to sell to a traditional publisher, or they’re unlikely to sign you as a client.” – Notaras
“[Self-publishing] is not that expensive anymore; it’s not out of reach. It’s not the way it used to be. Every one of you can do this, and it’s part of the democratization of publishing that’s actually been happening.” – Notaras
Traditional publishers don’t help much with marketing anyway
Publishers used to have much more marketing power. With the internet and social media, they’re not capable of getting the word out like they could.
That’s why it’s imperative that authors put in their own marketing work, traditionally published or not. Publishers provide some marketing, but that doesn’t guarantee a book’s success.
“That’s the biggest myth in all of publishing, that the publishers somehow will make you a success. The publishers can help get the book in the bookstores, they can get the books out there in the world. But in the end, it’s going to be the author that helps get them off the shelf and into people’s hands more than a publisher.” – Tracy
“Even someone who has a huge audience, the publisher doesn’t want them if they’re going to stop talking about the book the day it publishes, which a lot of people do.” – Notaras
“You might not love social media, but it does even the playing field so that everyone can get the information out about their books.” – Notaras
“There are so many books that I’ve published over my career that I absolutely loved, that the entire editorial team was behind, that the whole company was behind, but the audience didn’t find it for reasons unknown. It’s just part of the game of publishing.” – Tracy
You have full creative control (and get more money)
Working with a publisher is more of a collaborative process, and the author often has to relinquish some creative control in exchange for the contract. Publishers could require changes as extreme as adding or cutting entire chapters, or completely overhauling certain aspects of the book.
“You are agreeing together to give the publisher final say on the book because they are the ones that are taking the risk in selling it, meaning they need to be able to have some creative input if they don’t believe that certain aspects of the book are going to be saleable,” Notaras said.
If the author wants final say on every aspect, then self-publishing is the way to go. That includes details like accepting editing, when it’s ready to publish, the title, the cover design, and the cover price. And it typically comes with more money from each sale.
‘Book before the book’: Writing that first book can clear the cobwebs
Notaras said authors often have a personal story that takes space in their mind. And they need to write it down, regardless of whether readers would be interested, before they can focus on new projects. A “book before the book,” she called it.
In that case, self-publishing would be the best option.
“I say you’re writing for your heart or your art, and it’s not because you really want sell a ton of copies of the book; it’s because you need to write this book.” – Notaras
“Oftentimes, the book before the book is like a clog in the pipeline. They know that they’ve got other books they want to write, books that they know there’s an audience for. But this book … just needs to get out first, or the other books aren’t going to come out. They can’t really start thinking about the reader until they have fully expressed this part of themselves.” – Notaras
“And the book before the book may still deserve to be published. It may be something that you’ll want, your kids will want, your grandkids will want.” – Notaras
But remember, self-publishing is often associated with lower quality
Self-publishing can be as cheap or expensive as you want, they said. You can do everything yourself and pay almost nothing, or you can pay for book services like editing and marketing.
But circumventing any help probably will lead to a lower quality book. And because there are so many low-quality self-published books on the market, many people assume they are worse even if they might not be.
“Is it thought that traditional books are of higher quality? Statistically speaking, yes, because people who self-publish oftentimes don’t have the same financial backing that a traditional publisher would have. So they don’t have the budget to put in the kind of creative help that a traditional publisher is just automatically going to give the book. So that’s up to you. You have to decide how much you want to put into the book based on what your commitment is.” – Notaras
“The more help you do bring in, the very much more likely the book will be widely read, because it’s going to be improved by each person that works with you on it. And if you think about comparing your book to the book that’s published by a traditional house, they’re putting it through multiple rounds of editing; they’re putting it through copy editing and proofreading; they’re using a professional designer for the cover.” – Notaras

